During Allen's trial, a pair of teenage girls who were on the trail that day shared their recollections of the "bridge guy" with the jury. Railly Voorhies said the man she saw was overdressed for the weather, had on dark clothes, was wearing a hat and had his hands in his pockets.

A high-profile murder case that rocked a small Indiana town and captured the nation's attention is now in the hands of the jury. Jurors heard closing arguments on Thursday in the trial of the man accused of killing two teenage girls in 2017.